Society for Clinical Vascular Surgery
November 16, 2006

Non-operative active management of Critical Limb Ischaemia (CLI): Initial experience using a Sequential Compression Biomechanical Device (SCBD) for Limb Salvage.

Back to Annual Meeting
Back to Program
Olubumni Esan, MB BS MRCSI, Niamh Hynes, MB BCh BAO MD MRCSI, Anne Fahy DMP, Wael Tawfick MB BCh, MRCSI, Sherif Sultan, MB BCh MCh MD FRCSI EBQS/VASC.
Western Vascular Institute, Galway, Ireland.

Objectives: We aim to evaluate non-operative management using a SCBD in amputation-bound non-reconstructible CLI patients.
Composite-primary endpoints were limb-salvage, rest-pain resolution, toe pressure change and 90-day mortality. Second endpoints were popliteal artery bloodflow velocity(PABV) variation, ulcer healing and cost-effectiveness.
Methods: 35 patients (39 limbs: rest pain=12, tissue loss=27) presented over 24-months. 30 had non-reconstructible arterial outflow vessels. 5 were non-operable due to severe co-morbidity (ASA IV). 74% males. Mean age 74.3years. All were Rutherford classification IV/V with multiple level disease.
All underwent a 12-week treatment protocol and best medical treatment. Follow-up was 4-weekly with duplex scan, ankle-brachial pressure index and digital pressures.
Results: Mean follow-up was 10months(+/-SD 6months). One-year Cumulative Limb-salvage rate was 88%(+/-SE 7.62%). Ninety-day mortality was zero. Mean toe pressures increased from 38.2 to 61.9mmHg(95%CI -33.19-14.19). Analgesia requirements decreased from the 1st week (p< 0.0001).
PABV increased from 43.8 to 45.5cm/s2(95%CI (18.56-8.089). Mean hospital stay was 15days.
In a matched cohort of CLI patients in the preceding 24 months, 45 primary amputations were performed with mean hospital stay of 25days and one-year mortality rate of 84.4%(+/-SE 5.41%). This compares to one-year mortality of 84.5%(+/-SE 8.00%) in the SCBD cohort (p=0.93, hazard ratio=0.95, 95%CI[0.30 to 2.98]). Estimated median Inpatient/Total cost of managing a primary-amputation patient is €15,000/€29,815 compared to €9000/€13,900 for SCBD.
Conclusions: SCBD enhanced limb salvage, reduced length of hospital stay and provided rapid relief of rest pain without surgical intervention in patients with limited life expectancy with non-reconstructible lower limb arterial tree in a cost effective manner.


Back to Annual Meeting
Back to Program